🪙 MS63 vs. MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars: Which Grade Offers the Best Value for Collectors and Investors?
If you’re considering investing in or collecting Morgan Silver Dollars, you’ve likely encountered coins graded MS63 and MS64 by top third-party grading services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation). These two grades are among the most popular for buyers looking for high-quality, uncirculated coins without breaking the bank.
But what exactly is the difference between an MS63 and MS64 Morgan Dollar? More importantly, which grade offers the best value based on your goals?
In this post, we’ll break down the distinctions in grading, visual appeal, pricing trends, investment potential, and which grade is best depending on whether you’re buying for profit, history, or beauty.
🧠 Understanding Coin Grading: What Does MS63 and MS64 Mean?
The Sheldon Grading Scale, used by both PCGS and NGC, ranges from 1 to 70, with Mint State (MS) grades from 60–70 reserved for coins that show no signs of wear. The higher the grade, the better the coin’s condition—and typically, the higher its value.
| Grade | Description | Key Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| MS63 | Mint State 63 | Uncirculated coin with moderate contact marks, slightly weak luster |
| MS64 | Mint State 64 | Fewer and lighter marks, better luster and eye appeal |
🧐 What to Expect Visually
- MS63 coins are still bright and uncirculated but may have noticeable contact marks in focal areas like Liberty’s cheek or the eagle’s breast.
- MS64 coins have fewer marks, and those present tend to be less distracting. The overall strike and eye appeal is superior to MS63.
To the untrained eye, the differences might be subtle. But to a collector or investor, those small visual improvements can justify a price jump.
🪙 Spotlight: The Morgan Silver Dollar (1878–1904, 1921)
Before we dig deeper into grading differences, let’s take a moment to appreciate what makes the Morgan Silver Dollar so iconic.
- Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper
- Weight: 26.73 grams
- Designer: George T. Morgan
- Mint Marks: Philadelphia (no mark), San Francisco (S), New Orleans (O), Carson City (CC), and Denver (D – only 1921)
These coins were minted during the post-Civil War industrial boom and are prized for their large size, high silver content, and detailed designs.
Now, let’s compare MS63 and MS64 Morgans from a collector and investor perspective.
💵 Price Comparison: MS63 vs MS64
The price difference between MS63 and MS64 coins varies based on mint mark, year, and overall rarity, but in general, MS64 coins carry a notable premium over MS63 examples.
🧾 Average Price Ranges (Common Dates)
For rarer issues (e.g., CC mint marks or low-mintage years), the difference in price can be several hundred dollars or more.
Example:
- 1881-S MS63: ~$90
- 1881-S MS64: ~$120
While a $30 difference may not seem like much, when scaling up a collection or investment, it becomes more significant.
📈 Morgan Value Growth and Investment Potential
When investing in graded coins, your goal is to preserve capital and ideally realize gains over time.
🪙 MS63 Morgan Silver Dollar: A Safer, More Affordable Entry Point
- More abundant in supply
- Slightly lower appreciation potential
- Higher liquidity because more buyers can afford them
🌟 MS64 Morgan Silver Dollar: The Sweet Spot for Value and Upside
- Generally, lower populations than MS63
- Greater collector appeal due to superior eye appeal
- Higher potential for price appreciation, especially for certain dates/mint marks
In bull markets (like during rising silver prices or increased collector demand), MS64 coins often appreciate faster and hold value better than their MS63 counterparts.
🔍 Scarcity and Population Reports on Morgan Silver Dollars
Population reports from NGC and PCGS provide insights into how many coins of each grade exist.
Let’s use the 1884-O Morgan Dollar as an example:
| Grade | PCGS Population | NGC Population |
|---|---|---|
| MS63 | 500,000+ | 400,000+ |
| MS64 | 250,000+ | 230,000+ |
The MS64 version is roughly half as common, which partly explains the premium — supply and demand in action.
Keep in mind: the jump in value from MS64 to MS65 is usually far steeper, often doubling or tripling the price, which is why many investors target MS64 as the “sweet spot.”
🔧 Collector vs. Investor Perspective
👤 Collectors Prefer:
- Better eye appeal (fewer blemishes, stronger luster)
- Coins with clear strike details (especially in Liberty’s hair or the eagle’s feathers)
- Attractive toning, when present
For this reason, MS64 coins are more desirable in a display or legacy collection.
🧑💼 Investors Look For:
- Undervalued coins in high grades
- Coins with potential for future grade resubmission (e.g., high-end MS64s that might cross to MS65)
- Low-risk entries (MS63) when stacking quantity over quality
So the choice between MS63 vs. MS64 often depends on whether your focus is quality or quantity.
🛒 Where to Buy Trusted MS63 & MS64 Morgan Dollars
🔐 Verified Dealers
- Spring Hill Coin Shop: Online Coin Shop for Vermillion Enterprises
- Local Coin Shops (LCS): Good for inspecting coins in person
💡 Tips for Buying
- Stick with PCGS or NGC graded coins — they’re the most respected and liquid in the marketplace.
- Beware of raw (ungraded) coins listed as “MS63+” or “BU” — these are subjective and often overgraded.
- Look at multiple photos and ask for close-ups of key areas (e.g., cheek, fields) if buying online.
📝 Final Verdict: Morgan MS63 vs. MS64 – Which Should You Buy?
Both MS63 and MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars offer excellent value, but your best choice depends on your goals.
| Factor | Choose MS63 If… | Choose MS64 If… |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | You want the best value per dollar | You’re willing to pay a premium for beauty |
| Investment | You’re stacking multiple coins affordably | You’re seeking coins with better upside |
| Collecting | You’re building a bulk collection | You want a visually impressive, long-term collection |
| Resale Value | You plan to sell quickly or in bulk | You’re targeting appreciation and demand |
🎯 Our Recommendation:
If you’re investing long-term or building a standout collection, MS64 Morgans are worth the extra cost. But if you’re price-sensitive or stacking multiple coins, MS63 still gives you a beautiful, certified piece of American history at an excellent value.
🛍️ Shop Now: Find Your Next Graded Morgan Dollar
👉 MS63 Morgan Silver Dollars
👉 MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars
Both grades offer unique advantages — the key is to align your purchase with your financial goals and collecting passion.
Table of Contents