MS63 vs MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars: What’s the Difference and Which Should You Buy?
Morgan Silver Dollars are among the most iconic and widely collected coins in American numismatics. First struck in 1878 and produced through 1904, with a final issue in 1921, the Morgan Dollar has captivated collectors for over a century with its bold design, rich history, and 90% silver content.
But when it comes to collecting Morgans, grade matters—especially in the uncirculated range. Two of the most commonly encountered grades in the market are MS63 and MS64, both representing Mint State coins, but with subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) differences that can significantly impact a coin’s eye appeal, market value, and collector desirability.
In this in-depth guide, we’ll explore the real-world differences between MS63 and MS64 Morgan Dollars, how they’re graded, what to look for, and which might be the better choice depending on your collecting goals.
Understanding the Sheldon Grading Scale
Before diving into MS63 vs MS64 specifically, let’s briefly revisit what these numbers mean.
The Sheldon grading scale is a 70-point system used to describe the condition of a coin. It ranges from 1 (Poor) to 70 (Perfect Mint State). Once a coin reaches Mint State (MS)—meaning it shows no signs of wear from circulation—it enters a new range, from MS60 to MS70.
- MS60–MS62: Uncirculated but heavily marked or dull.
- MS63: Average Mint State with moderate marks and decent luster.
- MS64: Above-average with fewer and lighter marks, better luster, and eye appeal.
- MS65–MS67: Gem quality with strong strike, excellent luster, and minimal distractions.
- MS68–MS70: Near-perfect to perfect coins, extremely rare.
What Is a MS63 Morgan Dollar?
A MS63 Morgan Silver Dollar is a true uncirculated coin that retains full mint luster but has a noticeable number of moderate contact marks, especially in high points like Liberty’s cheek or the fields.
Key Features of MS63:
| Characteristic | MS63 |
|---|---|
| Luster | Present but may be interrupted by marks |
| Contact Marks | Several moderate marks or abrasions, especially in focal areas |
| Strike | Average to slightly soft in some areas |
| Eye Appeal | Respectable, but not exceptional |
| Certification | Graded and authenticated by PCGS or NGC |
MS63 coins are ideal for collectors who want unquestionably uncirculated coins without paying premium prices.
What Is a MS64 Morgan Dollar?
A MS64 Morgan Dollar represents the next step up in overall visual quality. While still uncirculated like MS63, it has fewer, smaller, or less distracting marks, brighter luster, and noticeably better eye appeal.
Key Features of MS64:
| Characteristic | MS64 |
|---|---|
| Luster | Full and mostly uninterrupted |
| Contact Marks | Fewer and lighter, typically off the focal points |
| Strike | Average to sharp, depending on the mint |
| Eye Appeal | Clearly better than MS63, often with vibrant fields |
| Certification | Graded by PCGS or NGC |
MS64 is often considered a “sweet spot” for serious collectors—a strong visual experience without gem-level prices.
MS63 vs MS64: Side-by-Side Comparison
Let’s break down the most critical differences between these two grades.
| Feature | MS63 | MS64 |
|---|---|---|
| Contact Marks | Moderate and often in focal areas (e.g., cheek, eagle’s breast) | Fewer marks, smaller in size, usually in less distracting locations |
| Luster | Good, but possibly broken or subdued | Stronger, more consistent, often attractive |
| Strike | Average; may have flat areas | Average to sharp; more detail present |
| Eye Appeal | Decent, but not standout | Above average and noticeably more pleasing |
| Market Value | Lower entry point for uncirculated Morgans | Commands a premium due to visual quality |
| Availability | Common for most dates | Slightly less common, especially for better strikes |
While both coins are uncirculated and free from wear, the cumulative impact of fewer flaws and stronger luster makes MS64 a more attractive coin—visually and in the marketplace.
Value Difference: MS63 vs MS64 Morgan Dollar
Here’s where the real distinction can come into play: price.
Even though the physical differences between MS63 and MS64 might appear minor to the untrained eye, the market places a clear premium on higher-graded coins.
Example (Random Common Date Morgan Dollar Pricing)*
| Grade | Approximate Price (Retail) |
|---|---|
| MS63 | $65–$85 |
| MS64 | $90–$140 |
*Prices vary based on silver spot price, demand, date, and certification.
For rare dates or mintmarks (e.g., 1893-CC, 1889-CC), the jump from MS63 to MS64 can mean hundreds or thousands of dollars in difference.
Eye Appeal: What Sets MS64 Apart
One of the biggest selling points for MS64 is eye appeal. While both grades are technically uncirculated, eye appeal is what draws a collector to a particular coin.
What gives MS64 coins better eye appeal?
- Fewer marks on the cheek and field—the first places collectors’ eyes go.
- Richer, brighter luster that reflects light better.
- Balanced toning, if present, that adds character without dulling the surface.
- Better strike detail, especially in Liberty’s hair and the eagle’s feathers.
For display, resale, or long-term holding, eye appeal matters—and MS64 consistently delivers more of it.
Which Grade Should You Buy?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The better choice depends on your budget, collection goals, and how much emphasis you place on visual perfection.
Choose MS63 Morgan if:
- You’re on a tighter budget and want a certified uncirculated coin.
- You’re building a large set and need consistency without overspending.
- You’re new to Morgan Dollars and want a safe, affordable entry point.
Choose MS64 Morgan if:
- You want a visually cleaner, more attractive coin.
- You’re building a high-quality type set or display collection.
- You’re considering resale value down the line—MS64 coins tend to be more marketable.
- You appreciate better luster and fewer distracting flaws.
Investment Perspective: Which Holds Value Better?
From an investment standpoint, MS64 coins tend to:
- Appreciate more steadily than MS63 coins over time.
- Offer higher liquidity—they’re easier to sell due to stronger demand.
- Have less competition from lower-priced substitutes.
However, MS63 coins can still serve as solid silver-based investments, especially for bulk purchases or for entry-level collectors building foundational portfolios.
Which Morgan Dollar Grade Offers More?
The leap from MS63 to MS64 may seem small on paper, but for collectors who value luster, strike quality, and overall eye appeal, it’s a meaningful step.
At SpringHillCoinShop.com, we offer both MS63 and MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars—random-year, common-date examples, graded and slabbed by PCGS or NGC. Our coins are ideal for collectors who want authentic, certified silver without overpaying.
Whether you choose MS63 for budget-conscious collecting or MS64 for a superior visual experience, you’re owning a piece of American history—and a beautiful one at that.
Shop Certified Morgan Dollars
👉 Buy MS63 Morgans
👉 Buy MS64 Morgans
Every coin we sell is 100% genuine, certified by PCGS or NGC, and carefully selected for quality and value.
Have Questions?
We’re here to help! Contact our team of numismatists anytime for assistance choosing the right Morgan Silver Dollar for your collection or investment portfolio.
- 👉 MS63 Morgan Silver Dollars – Certified, Common Date
- 👉 MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars – Certified, Common Date
- 👉 1/10 oz American Gold Eagles – Random Year
- 👉 Florida Gold Dealer
Table of Contents


