🪙 MS63 vs. MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars: Which Grade Offers the Best Value?
If you’re looking to invest in or collect Morgan Silver Dollars, you’ve likely come across the MS63 and MS64 grades—two of the most popular options for certified, uncirculated coins. But what’s the real difference, and which one offers better value?
This guide compares MS63 vs. MS64 Morgan Dollars in terms of grading standards, visual appeal, price, rarity, and investment potential, helping you choose the right coin for your budget and goals.
🧠 What Do MS63 and MS64 Mean?
Coins graded by top agencies like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) use the Sheldon Scale, which ranges from 1 to 70. Grades in the Mint State (MS) 60–70 range are uncirculated.
| Grade | Description | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| MS63 | Mint State 63 | Moderate marks, decent luster |
| MS64 | Mint State 64 | Fewer, lighter marks; better eye appeal |
Even though both grades are uncirculated, MS64 coins tend to be more attractive, with fewer distractions and stronger detail.
🧐 Visual Differences: What You’ll Notice
- MS63: May show visible contact marks on high points (like Liberty’s cheek or eagle’s breast).
- MS64: Smoother surfaces, fewer marks, and superior luster.
To a casual observer, the difference is subtle. But to investors and collectors, that extra eye appeal can mean a higher price tag and better resale value.
🪙 Spotlight: Why Morgan Silver Dollars Are Collectible
- Minted: 1878–1904, 1921
- Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper
- Weight: 26.73g
- Designer: George T. Morgan
- Popular Mints: Philadelphia, Carson City, New Orleans, San Francisco, Denver (1921 only)
Morgan Dollars are admired for their size, silver content, and historic significance—making them a favorite among U.S. coin collectors.
💵 MS63 vs. MS64: Price Comparison
| Grade | Avg. Price (Common Dates) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| MS63 Morgan Dollar | ~$80 | SpringHillCoinShop.com |
| MS64 Morgan Dollar | ~$105 | SpringHillCoinShop.com |
For rarer dates or mint marks, the price difference can be much larger.
Example: 1881-S Morgan Dollar
- MS63: ~$90
- MS64: ~$120
The $30 difference may seem minor, but it scales quickly if you’re building a large portfolio.
📈 Investment Potential: Which Grade Performs Better?
🪙 MS63 Morgan Dollar
- ✅ Lower entry price
- ✅ More available inventory
- ✅ Easier to resell due to affordability
🌟 MS64 Morgan Dollar
- ✅ Fewer available coins (lower population)
- ✅ Higher demand among collectors
- ✅ Greater upside potential during bull markets
MS64 coins tend to appreciate more consistently, especially in rising silver markets or when demand for higher-grade coins increases.
🔍 Rarity & Population Reports: Supply Matters
Population data from PCGS and NGC helps explain the value gap:
Example: 1884-O Morgan Dollar
| Grade | PCGS Population | NGC Population |
|---|---|---|
| MS63 | 500,000+ | 400,000+ |
| MS64 | 250,000+ | 230,000+ |
With nearly half the population, MS64 Morgans command a premium due to classic supply-and-demand economics.
🧑⚖️ Collector vs. Investor: Who Should Choose Which?
| Perspective | Choose MS63 If… | Choose MS64 If… |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | You want more coins for less | You’ll pay more for better quality |
| Investment | You’re stacking for silver content | You want coins with appreciation upside |
| Collecting | You’re building a volume collection | You value superior eye appeal |
| Resale | You plan to flip or trade frequently | You want stronger long-term returns |
🛒 Where to Buy MS63 and MS64 Morgan Dollars
✅ Trusted Online Coin Dealers
- SpringHillCoinShop.com
- Local coin shops (LCS) for in-person inspection
💡 Smart Buying Tips
- Only buy NGC or PCGS certified coins
- Avoid raw “BU” coins sold without grading
- Check for high-quality photos of key areas (Liberty’s cheek, eagle’s feathers)
📝 Final Verdict: MS63 Morgan or MS64 Morgan — Which Is Right for You?
Both MS63 and MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars offer strong value, but your best choice depends on your priorities:
- Choose MS63 if you’re building an affordable, bulk silver portfolio with high liquidity.
- Choose MS64 if you want premium coins with better eye appeal and greater long-term upside.
🛍️ Start Building Your Collection Today
👉 Buy MS63 Morgan Dollars
👉 Buy MS64 Morgan Dollars
Whether you’re a collector, investor, or both—Morgan Dollars in these grades offer a certified, historical piece of American silver with lasting value.
Table of Contents