Graded vs. Ungraded: Why Choose MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars?
Making the Smarter Choice in Coin Collecting
If you’ve been eyeing the iconic Morgan Silver Dollar, you’ve likely noticed two options: graded (certified) and ungraded (raw) coins. For new and seasoned collectors alike, this choice can dramatically affect your investment, peace of mind, and long-term value.
In this guide, we’ll explain why MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars, graded by NGC or PCGS, are the superior option—and why buying ungraded can be riskier than it seems.
What Does “Graded” Mean?
Graded coins are professionally authenticated and evaluated by third-party services like:
- NGC – Numismatic Guaranty Company
- PCGS – Professional Coin Grading Service
The coins are sealed in tamper-evident, protective holders with labels that include:
- Grade (e.g., MS64)
- Date and mint mark
- Serial number
- Authentication details
MS64: The Perfect Balance
An MS64 grade on the Sheldon Scale (1–70) means the coin is:
- Uncirculated
- Has original mint luster
- Shows only minimal contact marks
- Visually striking with strong overall appeal
The Key Differences: Graded vs. Ungraded
Let’s break it down in a side-by-side comparison:
| Feature | Graded MS64 Coin | Ungraded (Raw) Coin |
|---|---|---|
| Authenticity | Guaranteed by NGC/PCGS | No guarantee—subject to counterfeits |
| Grade Verification | Clearly documented, industry-accepted | Seller’s opinion only—may be inaccurate |
| Condition | Known: MS64 standard with eye appeal | Unknown until professionally evaluated |
| Protection | Sealed holder prevents damage or tampering | Vulnerable to wear, tarnish, and improper storage |
| Resale Value | Easier to resell, often at premium prices | Lower trust from buyers; harder to appraise |
| Peace of Mind | High – backed by expert assessment | Low – reliant on guesswork or seller claims |
5 Reasons to Choose MS64 Morgan Dollars
✅ 1. Guaranteed Authenticity
With counterfeits on the rise, NGC and PCGS-certified coins remove all doubt. The coin’s identity, metal content, and origin are verified by trusted experts using advanced tools.
“Buy the coin, not the story.” Graded coins tell the truth through certified documentation.
✅ 2. Protected, Preserved, and Presentation-Ready
Graded Morgan Dollars come encapsulated in a clear, hard plastic holder designed to:
- Prevent damage
- Avoid exposure to air and moisture
- Display the coin clearly for collectors
It’s ideal for both storage and display, while preserving the coin’s condition for decades.
✅ 3. Stronger Resale and Trade Value
Graded coins—especially MS64 Morgans—are far easier to sell in the future. Buyers trust:
- The certification
- The condition
- The legitimacy of the coin
Ungraded coins are often passed over or heavily discounted due to uncertainty. For collectors thinking long-term, grading = liquidity.
✅ 4. Know What You’re Paying For
Buying an ungraded Morgan Dollar at “mint state” pricing without verification is risky. You might be:
- Overpaying for a lower-grade coin
- Buying a cleaned or altered piece
- Getting a counterfeit
With MS64 graded coins, you know exactly what you’re receiving. The grade has been independently verified, giving you clarity and confidence.
✅ 5. Ideal for Building a High-Quality Collection
Starting or expanding a Morgan Dollar collection? MS64-graded coins are perfect because:
- They’re affordable compared to MS65+
- Offer premium eye appeal
- Allow consistency in your set’s quality
- Are available in random-year lots to help you discover new dates and mint marks
At SpringHillCoinShop.com, we offer a curated selection of certified MS64 Morgans, helping you build a solid foundation for any collection.
Common Myths About Ungraded Coins
❌ “I can tell a good coin by eye.”
Even experts make mistakes without tools. Professional grading uses microscopes, weight tests, surface analysis, and years of experience.
❌ “Grading is expensive and unnecessary.”
While grading services charge fees, buying pre-graded coins saves time and ensures you don’t overpay for uncertain quality.
❌ “I’ll get it graded later.”
That’s risky. If the coin turns out to be a lower grade or has issues (cleaning, damage, etc.), you may lose money or get denied certification entirely.
FAQs About Buying Graded Morgan Dollars
Q: Is MS64 a good grade for beginners?
Yes! MS64 is a sweet spot—offering excellent condition without the premium price of MS65 or higher.
Q: Can I build a full set of MS64 Morgans?
Absolutely. Many collectors aim to assemble a full date or mint mark set in MS64 grade because of the balance between value and quality.
Q: Where should I buy certified MS64 Morgan Dollars?
Stick to reputable dealers like SpringHillCoinShop.com, where coins are authenticated, clearly described, and securely shipped.
Final Thoughts: Choose Wisely, Collect Confidently
When it comes to Morgan Silver Dollars, graded MS64 coins are the clear choice for collectors who care about:
- ✅ Authenticity
- ✅ Condition
- ✅ Resale value
- ✅ Peace of mind
Ungraded coins might be cheaper upfront, but in the long run, graded Morgans offer more value, less risk, and a far more satisfying collecting experience.
👉 Explore our limited inventory of certified MS64 Morgan Dollars at SpringHillCoinShop.com and make your next purchase a guaranteed one. Of if you are local come to our Florida Coin shop, Vermillion Enterprises, in Spring Hill.
Table of Contents