Why Collectors Choose MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars Over MS63

Why Collectors Choose MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars Over MS63

When it comes to collecting Morgan Silver Dollars, the difference between a Mint State 63 (MS63) and a Mint State 64 (MS64) coin may seem subtle—but to seasoned collectors and savvy investors, that one-point difference can make a big impact.

At Spring Hill Coin Shop, we offer a trusted selection of NGC and PCGS-graded MS63 and MS64 Morgan Dollars from common dates spanning 1878 to 1904. While MS63 coins are a fantastic value, many collectors and investors choose to step up to MS64 for a number of compelling reasons. If you’re wondering whether it’s worth spending a bit more, this post will help you make an informed decision.


Understanding the Grading Scale: MS63 vs. MS64

Let’s start with a quick refresher. The 70-point Sheldon grading scale is used by third-party grading services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) to rate a coin’s condition.

  • MS63 (Mint State 63): A “Choice Uncirculated” coin with moderate contact marks, average luster, and okay eye appeal.
  • MS64 (Mint State 64): A “Choice Uncirculated” coin with fewer and lighter marks, better eye appeal, and more defined strike quality.

💡 The leap from MS63 to MS64 reflects a higher visual standard, better preservation, and often more collector demand.


Why Collectors and Investors Choose MS64 Morgan Dollars

Here are the top reasons many buyers choose MS64 Morgans over their slightly lower-graded counterparts.


✨ 1. Superior Eye Appeal

One of the biggest advantages of MS64 coins is their visual quality.

  • Fewer bag marks
  • Stronger luster
  • Cleaner fields and devices
  • Sharply struck details

Even slight differences in eye appeal can make a coin stand out in a collection. MS64 Morgans often have a brighter, more attractive presence, which is why they’re frequently chosen for display sets, gifts, and registry submissions.

📸 If you’re showcasing your collection or simply appreciate visual perfection, MS64 is a clear step up.


💎 2. Higher Market Demand

MS64 Morgan Dollars often experience higher demand in the numismatic marketplace, particularly among:

  • Advanced collectors
  • Competitive set builders
  • Investors focused on appreciation potential

Because MS64 represents a quality threshold just below gem (MS65), these coins are often more desirable, especially for high-end portfolios or collections curated with long-term value in mind.

📈 This demand typically translates to better resale potential when compared to lower-graded coins.


📊 3. Long-Term Appreciation Potential

While MS63 coins are excellent for budget-conscious buyers, MS64 coins tend to appreciate more predictably over time, especially for common-date Morgan Dollars.

As more collectors aim for higher grades, the demand curve shifts upward. MS64 coins offer a sweet spot: premium condition without the high premiums of MS65 or MS66 coins, which can double or triple in price.

🧠 Think of MS64 Morgans as a strategic mid-tier investment—premium enough to stand out, but still reasonably priced for consistent acquisition.


🔐 4. Better Registry Set Value

Many collectors submit their coins to NGC or PCGS Set Registries, where they compete based on grade and rarity. In these competitive environments, an MS64 coin will score higher and increase your overall set value compared to an MS63.

That means:

  • Greater registry points
  • Better placement on collector leaderboards
  • Increased bragging rights (yes, it matters!)

🏆 If registry building is part of your collecting journey, MS64 is the smarter choice.


💼 5. Professional Presentation

Let’s face it—when a coin is encapsulated and certified as MS64, it just carries more weight in conversations with dealers, appraisers, or fellow collectors. Higher grades project:

  • Professionalism
  • Pride in ownership
  • A more refined collecting taste

🖼️ Whether you’re sharing your collection or planning to pass it on, MS64 coins make a stronger impression.


🧭 6. Closer to Gem Status (MS65)

The move from MS63 to MS64 is the beginning of the transition into Gem Uncirculated territory (MS65+). If you’re working toward building a higher-grade collection but aren’t ready to pay Gem premiums, MS64 offers a compelling middle ground.

Here’s why:

  • MS64 coins are closer in quality to Gem than MS63
  • Less competition than MS65 and MS66, so easier to acquire
  • Strong upside potential if the market pushes demand for higher-grade Morgans

🪙 Many collectors view MS64 as the perfect balance between cost and quality.


Use Case: Display-Grade Collecting

Let’s say you’re building a display-grade Morgan Dollar set to showcase at home or at coin shows. You want consistency, strong eye appeal, and coins you can be proud of.

With MS64:

  • You maintain a uniform look across your collection
  • Each coin looks sharp and clean under magnification
  • Your set stands out visually—even among higher-grade collections

💬 The quality difference between MS64 and MS63 is noticeable in person, especially under lighting or magnification.


Morgan Dollars: A Quick Overview

The Morgan Silver Dollar (minted 1878–1904 and again in 1921) is one of the most popular U.S. coins to collect. Designed by George T. Morgan, these coins represent the spirit of 19th-century American coinage.

Key facts:

  • Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper
  • Weight: 26.73 grams
  • Diameter: 38.1 mm
  • Mints: Philadelphia, New Orleans, San Francisco, Carson City

Even common-date Morgan Dollars in higher grades like MS64 can offer significant collector and investment value.


Why Buy MS64 Morgan Dollars from Spring Hill Coin Shop?

At Spring Hill Coin Shop, we specialize in offering certified, high-grade coins at competitive prices. Whether you’re building a top-tier collection or investing for the future, we offer MS64 Morgan Dollars that meet your goals.

Here’s what sets us apart:

✅ Genuine NGC & PCGS Graded Coins
✅ Competitive Pricing with Transparent Premiums
✅ Fast, Insured Shipping Nationwide
✅ In-Person Support at Our Florida Store
✅ Expert Guidance for New and Advanced Collectors

We don’t just sell coins—we help build collections with lasting value.


Final Thoughts: Is MS64 Worth It?

If you’re looking for a coin with:

  • Better eye appeal
  • Greater marketability
  • Higher registry value
  • Stronger long-term upside

Then MS64 Morgan Silver Dollars are absolutely worth the upgrade.

It’s more than just a number on a slab. It’s a statement of quality, commitment, and confidence in your collection.

🛒 Explore our MS64 Morgan Dollar inventory at SpringHillCoinShop.com
📍 Or visit us in Spring Hill, Florida for in-person service and expert advice

1878 - 1904 NGC / PCGS Morgan Dollar Silver Coin Random Year MS64

Leave a Reply