Why Smart Collectors Choose MS63 Morgan Dollars Over MS64

Why Smart Collectors Choose MS63 Morgan Silver Dollars Over MS64

When it comes to collecting Morgan Silver Dollars, collectors often find themselves choosing between two closely related options: MS63 and MS64 graded coins. At first glance, the difference seems minor—just a single point on the 70-point grading scale. But for informed buyers, that one-point difference carries significant implications for value, affordability, and strategy.

At Spring Hill Coin Shop, we offer a variety of common date, random year Morgan Silver Dollars (1878–1904) certified by NGC and PCGS in both MS63 and MS64 grades. While MS64 coins offer slightly higher visual quality, there are compelling reasons many collectors prefer MS63 Morgans—and today, we’ll explore why.


Understanding Morgan Dollar Grading

Before diving into comparisons, let’s clarify what these grades actually mean.

  • MS63 (Mint State 63): Coins graded MS63 are considered “choice uncirculated.” They show some contact marks and abrasions but still retain strong luster and eye appeal.
  • MS64 (Mint State 64): Also “choice uncirculated,” MS64 coins have fewer and smaller marks than MS63s, with slightly better eye appeal and strike quality.

🔍 While the difference in appearance may be subtle, the difference in price and collecting strategy is often substantial.


Why Choose MS63 Over MS64?

Here are the key reasons many collectors and investors actively seek out MS63 Morgan Dollars:


💰 1. Affordability Without Compromise

MS63 Morgans offer real value—you’re still getting a certified, uncirculated coin, but without paying the premium for near-pristine condition.

For common dates, the price difference between MS63 and MS64 can be 30–50% or more, depending on the coin. For example, a common date MS63 might cost $80–$120, while the same coin in MS64 could run $150 or more.

That extra margin could allow you to:

  • Buy more coins
  • Diversify across different dates and mint marks
  • Stay within budget while still acquiring graded, investment-grade silver

📈 Better budget allocation means more flexibility in building your collection or investment portfolio.


📦 2. Higher Availability = Easier Completion

Because MS63 Morgan Dollars are more readily available than MS64s, they’re ideal for collectors building out a full set. Trying to assemble every date and mint mark in MS64 condition is both costly and time-consuming. MS63 coins provide a practical alternative.

With greater inventory on the market, it’s easier to:

  • Find specific dates or mintmarks
  • Match coins with similar toning or luster
  • Make faster progress toward completing your Morgan Dollar set

🧩 If you’re working on a registry set or just love the hunt, MS63 gives you more options without compromise.


🛡️ 3. Certified Security

All MS63 coins we sell are NGC or PCGS certified, meaning you’re getting:

  • Verified authenticity
  • Guaranteed grade
  • A coin preserved in a tamper-evident holder

You can collect with confidence knowing that your MS63 coin is genuine, graded, and backed by professional standards—the same as an MS64, just with more favorable pricing.


🔄 4. Greater Liquidity and Flexibility

Because MS63 Morgans are more affordable and widely collected, they offer excellent liquidity. These coins are in high demand among:

  • Beginner collectors
  • Budget-conscious investors
  • Dealers looking to replenish inventory

Whether you’re buying or selling, MS63 Morgans tend to move faster, making them an attractive choice for those who want flexibility to trade or cash out when needed.

💡 Want to start a trading strategy or use coins as barter assets? MS63s make that possible.


🧠 5. Smarter Cost Averaging for Investors

Precious metals investors often practice cost averaging—buying at different price points to reduce overall risk. MS63 coins are ideal for this approach. Instead of saving up for a single MS64, you can buy two or even three MS63s, diversifying your holdings over time.

That means:

  • More coins in hand
  • Greater protection against market swings
  • Better long-term appreciation potential

📊 This strategy isn’t just financially sound—it’s psychologically rewarding. Watching your collection grow coin by coin can be incredibly motivating.


🎨 6. Real Character and Vintage Charm

Collectors know that perfection isn’t always the goal—especially with coins over a century old. MS63 Morgans often show a bit of character: minor contact marks, unique toning, and subtle variances that give each coin a story.

While MS64 coins may look slightly cleaner, MS63s can be:

  • Just as attractive (especially with strong luster)
  • Rich in historical feel
  • More “authentic” to the eye of traditionalists

🌟 Many collectors actually prefer MS63 coins for their vintage aesthetic and individuality.


Use Case: Building a 20-Coin Type Set

Let’s say you want to build a 20-coin type set of Morgan Dollars from 1878–1904. You could spend ~$3,000–$4,000 if you go all MS64. But with MS63 coins, you might build that same set for $1,800–$2,500, depending on dates and dealers.

That’s a 40% savings—or a chance to buy 8–10 more coins, a new display case, or even a few Peace Dollars to expand your collection.


About Morgan Silver Dollars (1878–1904)

These iconic coins were minted in the wake of the Comstock Lode silver boom and have become one of the most collected U.S. coin series ever.

  • Designer: George T. Morgan
  • Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper
  • Diameter: 38.1 mm
  • Weight: 26.73 grams
  • Mintmarks: Philadelphia, New Orleans, San Francisco, Carson City

Even common-date Morgans in MS63 grade hold strong historical and investment value—and they’re tangible links to American history.


Why Buy from Spring Hill Coin Shop?

Here at Spring Hill Coin Shop, we specialize in providing collectors with certified, high-quality U.S. coins—including Morgan Dollars in MS63 and MS64.

What sets us apart:

✅ Accurate Grading: All coins are certified by NGC or PCGS
✅ Competitive Pricing: We monitor the market to offer fair, transparent rates
✅ Real Inventory: No gimmicks or drop-shipping—we stock what we sell
✅ Fast, Insured Shipping: Safe delivery, every time
✅ Expert Service: Questions? Our team is here to help

🛒 Browse our inventory online or visit us in person for personalized guidance.


Choose MS63 with Confidence

If you’re collecting for passion, investing for the long term, or simply building a silver portfolio, MS63 Morgan Silver Dollars offer unbeatable value. They strike the perfect balance between quality, affordability, and historical charm.

Don’t be swayed by the temptation of a slightly higher grade if it stretches your budget. Choosing MS63 isn’t settling—it’s strategic.

🛍️ Start your Morgan Dollar collection today at SpringHillCoinShop.com
📍 Or visit our Spring Hill, FL location for in-person help and expert advice

1878 - 1904 NGC / PCGS Morgan Dollar Silver Coin Random Year MS63

Leave a Reply